|
Republic Bank Angel Harps News Panorama Criteria Friday, 11th Aug. 2006 - "They tief, they tief. They tief we again". It's a cry that you would hear often in Grenada's carnival especially after the judges have given their final positions for participants and performers in the various carnival competitions. For the Panorama competition, expect no difference - some fans and supporters of the bands taking part in this year's competition will first look to blame the judges for their band's predicament. It's all so easy for us to do our own judging, using our own criteria and having to account to no one for our decisions. Judging competitions is never an easy task, but with the help of a set of established criteria, those persons judging competitions can more or less be judging the same thing at least from on the same page. ncbangelharps.com takes a close look at the break down of criteria points for panorama and invites all arm chair panorama judges to arm themselves with the tools for a more effective analysis of this years competition and results. There are four general areas for the awarding of points in panorama. These four areas are (1) Arrangement (2) General Performance (3) Tone and (4) Rhythm. There are specific sub-areas for these general areas where a further break down of points are made. (1) For Arrangement, a total of forty (40) points are available to the band. Bands may gain/lose points over four sub-areas under Arrangement. Introduction: (8) points - the composition, by the arranger, of an appropriate introduction for the calypso chosen as the prepared piece. Within the context of this opening passage by the band, points may be gained by having a count that is clear, demanding attention and at the right tempo. Execution by the players should be flawless showing good balance and perfect intonation. Re-harmonization: (12) - the ability of the arranger to re-harmonize the calypso chosen as the prepared piece. After the calypso has been played in its original form (harmonically) the re-harmonization could be limited to one specific section or could be applied to the remainder of the arrangement. Melodic Development: (8) - the ability of the arranger to embellish/solo on, and utilize rhythmic variations of the melody in the arrangement. Motivic Development: (8) - the ability of the arranger to take a melodic motif(s) of the calypso and effectively utilize it (them) during the arrangement. Some arrangers may chose a particular line, a phrase or sometimes just a single note and develop on it in as many ways they wish.
(2) Another Forty (40) points are available for General Performance Interpretation: (12) - ability to creatively execute arrangement and all nuances. Leads should be clear and embellishments supportive. Dynamics: (10) - the effective execution of crescendos, de-crescendos, contrasts, phrasing, and other musical expressions in the arrangement.
Creativity: (10) - the artistry and skill with which the arranger modifies the melody and by extension the artistry and skill with which the players execute this Balance: (8) - distribution of parts of arrangements to all sections of the orchestra. All aspects of the arrangement must be audible throughout the performance. It is in this area that the level of preparation by the steel orchestra will pay off in points. How cleanly they can navigate the more difficult passages and the runs, the confidence and body language with which they execute their pieces, the fun they experience while playing - its all going to help rack up the points. (3) Another ten (10) points for Tone Blending of Pans: - blending is the overall tone/colour of the pans, including the consistency of tuning within the steelband. Blending is the term used in pan circles for what most people would consider as "tuning up" the band.
While 5 of these points are dependent on the pan Tuner (the consistency in the blending of the instruments), the type of sticks and quality of the rubber used, plus the general technique of the players will impact on the rich quality of sound for which a further five points are available. (4) And the final ten (10) points for Rhythm Application of Rhythm Section:
So be your own judge this year, go down to Panorama 2006 and support your band. But always remember, the decision of the "real" judges are always final. Enjoy your Carnival !! © 2006, Republic Bank Angel Harps. |